View by category
How can I manage Automated Reviewer Reminders in Editorial Manager?
Last updated on July 13, 2022Watch this short video to see how to send reviewer reminders.
Automated Reviewer Reminders in EM are based on creating specific Automated Reviewer Reminder Reports. Each report defines certain criteria, and links to a specific letter template. Each day all the configured reports are processed in one batch between 04:00-08:00 EST/EDT, and all eligible Reviewers receive a reminder email. Under normal circumstances, each Automated Reviewer Reminder Report will trigger no more than once per reviewer invitation or agreed review assignment.
The nightly batch reminder process runs between 12:00 AM - 04:00AM US Eastern time.
In some journals, permission to create Automated Reminder Reports is restricted to central roles such as Journal Managers Editorial Office, or Managing Editors. This is to reduce the risk of editors creating overlapping reminders that send too many reminders to the same recipient.
See below for steps to create or update Automated Reviewer Reminders. For a more general explanation of how the reminders work, see How are Automated Reviewer Reminders sent from Editorial Manager?
How
To set up Automated Reviewer Reminders:
- Check with your Journal Manager or Editorial Office what automated reminders may already be set up.
- Plan out what reminders you will need of what type.
- Each reminder will be set for so many days before or after a due date or other milestone.
- To send multiple reminders, for example 3 days past due and again at 10 days past due, then you must create separate reports for each reminder days value.
- Your Journal Manager can help you with planning out reminder schedules.
- If you will be personally creating the reminders, coordinate with your Journal Manager or Editorial Office to make sure all the letter templates you need are in place before beginning, and that you know the names of the templates to use.
- Under Administrative Functions in your main menu, click 'Send Reminder Letters'. If this is not listed, you do not have permission to send any manual or automated reminders.
- Click the Automated Reviewer Reminder Report link. If the link is not there, then you are not able to create Automated Reviewer Reminders.
- Scroll to the very bottom of the form, and check the list of Saved Automated Reminders. For those you created personally there will be links to edit or remove the report. If the report was created by someone else, you can see the reminder type and number of days but the edit and remove links will not appear.
- To edit a report you previously created, click the pencil icon and the form will reload with the details of the saved report.
- To create a new report, scroll back to the top of the page and continue with the next step to complete the form.
- If someone else has saved a report of the same type you are planning, you may want to check with that person to ensure you are not conflicting.
- Select the specific Reminder Type, and enter a number of days in that row. The types are:
- No Response. Send Reminder: reminds reviewers exactly X days after they were invited.
- Reminder Before Due Date: reminds reviewers who have agreed, or who have been assigned without invitation, exactly X days before the due date. 0 is not allowed as a value, and reviewers with blank due dates will not be reminded.
- Reminder Past Due Date: reminds reviewers who have agreed, or who have been assigned without invitation, exactly X days after the due date. 0 can be used as the value to send a reminder exactly on the due date. Reviewers with blank due dates will not be reminded.
- Reminder Outstanding Partially Saved Reviews: reminds reviewers who saved a review exactly X days ago and have not yet submitted their review.
- Partially Saved Reviews: if you have chosen Before Due or Past Due reminder type, select how to handle reviewers who have saved a review. Some potential uses of this option:
- Exclude partially saved reviews from due date reminders, and let those reviewers receive reminders based on the Outstanding Partially Saved report that is sent X days after they saved.
- Save one report with partial reviews excluded, and then save a different report with only those with partially saved reviews, use a different letter template for each.
- Enter a Reminder Name.
- Select a Reminder letter from the drop-down list.
- All letters defined as Reviewer Reminder letters will be available.
- In most journals the name will include 'automated' or 'auto' when the letter wording is suitable for an automated report.
- Optionally filter by a single Reviewer Role, for example if different letters need to be sent to different reviewer roles.
- Optionally filter by a single Handling Editor (last assigned editor). Note that some editors have a restricted reminder permission, in which case only submissions that editor was assigned to (not only has handling editor) are included in the report.
- Optionally filter by Section and/or Article Type.
- CTRL-click to select multiple options.
- Use the 'Clear All' link to de-select everything, so no filter is applied. This ensures that if new sections or article types are added to the journal they will be included in the report.
- Click 'Save Automated Reminder' for a new report, or 'Submit' if editing an existing report.
The report will be run in the next nightly batch, and send reminders to authors who meet the exact number of days criteria at that time.
Could one Reviewer be skipped or reminded twice?
- If a reviewer assignment has a blank due date, they cannot be reminded using the Before Due Date / Past Due Date report types. See How can I view or change a Reviewer Due Date in Editorial Manager?
- It is possible by changing either the parameters of the report, or the due date of an Reviewer task, for an Reviewer to be skipped or reminded twice on the same day or very close together. For example:
- If the definition of the report is edited from day to day, this can mean that a submission was eligible before the edit and so got one reminder, and then is eligible again after the edit and so gets another the next day.
- In the same way, editing a report could mean some Reviewers get no reminder, because they were not eligible yet before the edit, and are past the point of eligibility after the edit.
- For reports based on Before or Past Due Date, if the due date is updated for a submission or invitation then it is possible that the Reviewer could get more reminders than planned, or fewer.
- Each saved automated report is evaluated every day and reminders are sent to whatever submissions are valid on that day, no matter what may have been true the day before.
- If Before/Past due dates reports do not exclude those with partially saved reviews, and there is an Outstanding Partially saved report as well, then reviewers could receive those reminders at the same time.
- If multiple editors create Automated Reminders, they may define reminders that trigger for the same submission at close to the same time.
- If they are not restricted to remind only their own assignments this could easily result in Reviewers getting multiple reminders on the same day or consecutive days.
- Even if editors are restricted, if two editors have both been assigned to one submission and both have set up automated reminders, then the Reviewer could get too many reminders.
Can a Reviewer be excluded from automated reminders?
Users can be excluded from reminders by a setting in the user account; not all editors have permission to update this setting. The exclusion covers all reminders, manual and automated, for author, reviewer, and editor tasks.
- From your main menu, select 'Search People' and locate the user. See How can an Editor search for submissions or people? for more details
- Click the user name to open the record. See Screenshot.
- In the left side bar at the bottom, find Exclude this user from receiving all batch and reminder emails.
- Pick an option of 'Always', or 'When Unavailable dates are active'. See How do I let a journal know I am temporarily Unavailable using Editorial Manager?
- Scroll to the bottom of the page and click 'Submit' to save the change.
Who can create and manage Automated Reviewer Reminder Reports
In most journals, permission to create Automated Reviewer Reminders is restricted to central roles such as Journal Manager, Editorial Office, or Managing editors. This is to reduce the risk of editors creating overlapping reminders that send too many reminders to the same recipient. Editors with permission to create Automated Reviewer Reminder Reports can see the full list of what reports exist and who created them but are only able to edit those reports they personally have created.
An Editor's reminder permission may be restricted with the option 'Restrict Reminder Reports to Assigned Submissions', in this case reminders created by that editor will be sent only for submitting they are assigned to, either as the handling editor or as a another editor in the chain. This setting applies to automated and manual reminders.
Did we answer your question?
Related answers
Video Guide: Sending reviewer reminders in Editorial Manager
How do I respond to an invitation to review in Editorial Manager?
Can you check if my manuscript is suitable for submission?
What can I do if line numbering displays incorrectly in my submission PDF?
Can I request a split invoice for two institutions when ordering Open Access?
Recently viewed answers
Functionality disabled due to your cookie preferences